NCAA

The Top NCAA Wrestling Point Scorers Of The Past Decade

The Top NCAA Wrestling Point Scorers Of The Past Decade

Dive into the data and check out which wrestlers have accrued the most team points for their programs at the NCAA Championships in the last decade.

Jul 2, 2024 by Andy Hamilton
The Top NCAA Wrestling Point Scorers Of The Past Decade

It’s been a star-studded decade for college wrestling. 

The college game has produced nine World and Olympic champions during the past 10 years and nine others who have captured medals on international wrestling’s biggest stage. 

Additionally, the four-time NCAA champion club has grown from three members to seven during that time frame. 

One of the ways to compare the greats of that time frame: Stack them up based on the team points they accrued for their programs at the NCAA Championships. It’s not a perfect comparison, of course. Some of the greats of that time frame — like David Taylor and Logan Stieber, for example — only wrestled in one or two NCAA tournaments during that stretch, while several others competed in five. 

Nonetheless, here’s a comprehensive breakdown of the top point scorers from the past decade. 

Top 100

RankNameSchoolPointsTournaments Average
1Jason NolfPenn State98424.5
2Bo NickalPenn State95.5423.9
3Aaron BrooksPenn State94.5423.6
4Zain RetherfordPenn State93.5423.4
5Daton FixOklahoma State90518
6Spencer LeeIowa89.5422.4
7Kyle SnyderOhio State89422.3
8Carter Starocci Penn State87421.8
9Yianni DiakomihalisCornell84421
10Keegan O'TooleMissouri83.5420.9
11Isaiah MartinezIllinois82.5420.6
12J'den CoxMissouri80420
13David CarrIowa State79.5419.9
14Gabe DeanCornell77.5419.4
14Nathan TomaselloOhio State77.5419.4
16Vito ArujauCornell77419.3
16Myles AmineMichigan77515.4
18Alex DieringerOklahoma State74.5324.8
19Nick LeePenn State74418.5
20Parker KeckeisenNorthern Iowa72418
21Myles MartinOhio State70.5417.6
22Greg Kerkvliet Penn State69417.3
23Roman Bravo-YoungPenn State68417
23Michael KemererIowa68417
23Jaydin EiermanMissouri/Iowa68513.6
26Zahid ValenciaArizona State67.5322.5
27Bo JordanOhio State67416.8
27Mekhi LewisVirginia Tech67513.4
29Hayden HidlayNorth Carolina State66.5416.3
29Nick SurianoPenn State/Rutgers/Michigan66.5416.3
31Cory Clark Iowa65.5416.4
32Trent HidlayNorth Carolina State65416.3
33Gable StevesonMinnesota64.5321.5
33Mason ParrisMichigan64.5416.1
33Daniel LewisMissouri64.5416.1
36Shane GriffithStanford/Michigan63.5415.9
37Vincenzo JosephPenn State62320.7
38Nick GwiazdowskiNorth Carolina State61.5320.5
39Brandon SorensenIowa61415.3
40Austin O'Connor North Carolina 60.5415.2
41Mark HallPenn State60320
42Cohlton SchultzArizona State58414.5
43Sebastian RiveraNorthwestern/Rutgers57.5414.4
43Adam CoonMichigan57.5414.4
45Nahshon GarrettCornell55318.3
45Logan MassaMichigan55511
47Thomas GilmanIowa54.5318.2
47Pat GloryPrinceton54.5318.2
47Dean HeilOklahoma State54.5413.6
50Stevan MicicMichigan53.5413.4
50Micah JordanOhio State53.5413.4
50Austin DeSantoDrexel/Iowa53.5413.4
53Logan StieberOhio State52.5226.3
53Joey McKennaStanford/Ohio State52.5413.1
53Bernie TruaxCal Poly/Penn State52.5413.1
56Kollin MooreOhio State51.5317.2
56Anthony AshnaultRutgers51.5412.9
56Max DeanCornell/Penn State51.5412.9
59Cody BrewerOklahoma50.5316.8
59Ryan DeakinNorthwestern50.5412.6
61Bryce MeredithWyoming49.5316.5
61Real WoodsStanford/Iowa49.5412.4
63Jacob WarnerIowa49412.3
64Evan WickWisconsin/Cal Poly48.5316.2
64Wyatt HendricksonAir Force48.5412.1
66Sammy SassoOhio State48316
67Rocky ElamMissouri47.5411.9
67Isaac JordanWisconsin47.5411.9
67Brian RealbutoCornell47.5411.9
70Mike Labriola Nebraska47411.8
71TJ DudleyNebraska45.5411.4
71Seth GrossSouth Dakota State/Wisconsin45.5315.2
71Tariq WilsonNorth Carolina State45.5411.4
74Tyler BergerNebraska45315
74Ethan LizakMinnesota45411.3
76Michael McGeeOld Dominion/Arizona State44.558.9
77Levi HainesPenn State44222
77Nino BonaccorsiPittsburgh44411
77Lavion MayesMissouri44411
80Brandon CourtneyArizona State43.5314.5
80Jacori TeemerArizona State43.5314.5
82Kyven GadsonIowa State43221.5
82Morgan McIntoshPenn State43314.3
82Darian CruzLehigh43410.8
85Kevin JackNorth Carolina State42410.5
86Jason TsirtsisNorthwestern/Arizona State41.5410.4
87Mitchell PortEdinboro40.5220.3
87Jared HaughtVirginia Tech40.5313.5
87Austin GomezIowa State/Wisconsin/Michigan40.5410.1
87Dustin PlottOklahoma State40.5410.1
91Stephen BuchananWyoming/Oklahoma40313.3
91Kyle ParcoFresno State/Arizona State40410
93Cameron AmineMichigan39.5312.5
93Lucas DavisonNorthwestern/Michigan39.549.9
95James GreenNebraska39219.5
95Ian MillerKent State39313
97Tony CassioppiIowa38.5312.8
97Alec PantaleoMichigan38.549.6
97Peyton RobbNebraska38.549.6
100Bryce AndonianVirginia Tech3849.5

Highest Average (Number of NCAA tournaments since 2014) 

1. David Taylor — 27 (1) 

2. Logan Stieber — 26.3 (2) 

3. Alex Dieringer — 24.8 (3) 

4. Jason Nolf — 24.5 (4) 

4. Ed Ruth — 24.5 (1) 

6. Anthony Cassar — 24 (1) 

7. Bo Nickal — 23.9 (4) 

8. Aaron Brooks — 23.6 (4) 

9. Zain Retherford — 23.4 (4) 

10. Zahid Valencia — 22.5  (3) 

11. Spencer Lee — 22.4 (4) 

12. Kyle Snyder — 22.3 (4) 

13. Levi Haines — 22 (2)

13. Chris Perry — 22 (1) 

15. Carter Starocci — 21.8 (4)

17. Gable Steveson — 21.5 (3)

17. Kyven Gadson — 21.5 (2) 

19. Yianni Diakomihalis — 21 (4) 

20. Keegan O’Toole — 20.9 (4) 

Highest Tournament Point Totals Since 2014

28.5 — Zain Retherford (2016)

28 — Retherford (2017) 

27.5 — Bo Nickal (2017)

27 — Aaron Brooks (2024), Spencer Lee (2018), Nickal (2019), Jason Nolf (2017), David Taylor (2014)

26.5 — Kyven Gadson (2015), Logan Stieber (2014) 

26 — Levi Haines (2024), Parker Keckeisen (2024), Nolf (2019), Stieber (2015)

25 — Cody Brewer (2015), J’den Cox (2016), Alex Dieringer (2016), Dieringer (2015), Retherford (2018), Zahid Valencia (2019)  

Most Points By Weight Since 2014 

125: Spencer Lee — 89.5

133: Daton Fix — 90

141: Nick Lee — 74

149: Zain Retherford — 81.5

157: Jason Nolf — 98

165: Keegan O’Toole — 83.5

174: Carter Starocci — 87

184: Parker Keckeisen — 72

197: J’den Cox — 80

285: Kyle Snyder — 71

Top 100 Breakdown By School 

Penn State — 15: 1. Jason Nolf, 2. Bo Nickal, 3. Aaron Brooks, 4. Zain Retherford, 8. Carter Starocci, 19. Nick Lee, 22. Greg Kerkvliet, 23. Roman Bravo-Young, 29. Nick Suriano, 37. Vincenzo Joseph, 41. Mark Hall, 53. Bernie Truax, 56. Max Dean, 77. Levi Haines, 82. Morgan McIntosh 

Michigan — 11: 16. Myles Amine, 29. Nick Suriano, 33. Mason Parris, 36. Shane Griffith, 43. Adam Coon, 45. Logan Massa, 50. Stevan Micic, 87. Austin Gomez, 93. Cameron Amine, 93. Lucas Davison, 97. Alec Pantaleo

Iowa — 10: 6. Spencer Lee, 23. Michael Kemerer, 23. Jaydin Eierman, 31. Cory Clark, 39. Brandon Sorensen, 47. Thomas Gilman, 50. Austin DeSanto, 61. Real Woods, 63. Jacob Warner, 97. Tony Cassioppi

Ohio State — 9: 7. Kyle Snyder, 14. Nathan Tomasello, 21. Myles Martin, 27. Bo Jordan, 50. Micah Jordan, 53. Logan Stieber, 53. Joey McKenna, 56. Kollin Moore, 66. Sammy Sasso 

Arizona State — 7: 26. Zahid Valencia, 42. Cohlton Schultz, 76. Michael McGee, 80. Brandon Courtney, 80. Jacori Teemer, 86. Jason Tsirtsis, 91. Kyle Parco 

Cornell — 6: 9. Yianni Diakomihalis, 14. Gabe Dean, 16. Vito Arujau, 45. Nahshon Garrett, 56. Max Dean, 67. Brian Realbuto 

Missouri — 6: 10. Keegan O’Toole, 12. J’den Cox, 23. Jadyin Eierman, 33. Daniel Lewis, 67. Rocky Elam, 77. Lavion Mayes 

Nebraska — 5: 70. Mike Labriola, 71. T.J. Dudley, 73. Tyler Berger, 95. James Green, 97. Peyton Robb 

North Carolina State — 5: 29. Hayden Hidlay, 32. Trent Hidlay, 38. Nick Gwiazdowski, 71. Tariq Wilson, 85. Kevin Jack